Perfect World
Las Cruces
← All checked meetings

Redline · October 7, 2024

Las Cruces Council Meeting - October 7, 2024

The city’s minutes for this meeting were compared, sentence by sentence, against the transcript of the recording. Of 63 statements the minutes attribute to a named person, 63 were found in the recording.

Tracks the recording closely. The comparison is mechanical and has no opinion about why two documents differ. A gap can be honest summarising; a mismatch can be the caption software mishearing. Both texts are shown so you can decide, and the correction form at the bottom is there for when the machine is wrong.

90match score /100
16,181words in the minutes
27,175words on the recording
6,760spoken words with no counterpart

Watch the recording · Read the minutes as text · The city’s original PDF · checked 8/14/2026

17 differences

Every difference the check found, including ones ordinary summarising explains. Show only the serious ones

~2470 words of the recording have no counterpart in the minutes

Missing from the minutes

This part of the meeting left no trace in the written record. This stretch of the meeting is not reflected anywhere in the written record. Some gaps are legitimate — recesses, or a presentation summarised in one line. Others are discussion that simply did not make it in. 1 person introduce themselves by name inside this gap. It contains: “fine”, “corrupt”, “investigation”, “resign”, “discrimination”.

What the minutes say

Nothing — this passage is absent from the minutes.

What the recording says

theme is honoring veteran First Responders today's presentation is to announce the top five local artists and reward them for their efforts we judged approximately 82 submissions from Mesa Lynn Picacho White Sands and Zia Middle Schools I'd like to have the uh artist please come forward after careful consideration the top five artists are in alphabetical order samanta CIO Jasline Horvath Eli Ooa Emma r and enzen who is not present at the moment could we please give them a round of applause for the outstanding efforts thank you

~650 words of the recording have no counterpart in the minutes

Missing from the minutes

This part of the meeting left no trace in the written record. This stretch of the meeting is not reflected anywhere in the written record. Some gaps are legitimate — recesses, or a presentation summarised in one line. Others are discussion that simply did not make it in. 1 person introduce themselves by name inside this gap. It contains: “contamination”, “condemnation”.

What the minutes say

Nothing — this passage is absent from the minutes.

What the recording says

and as such silence is complicity I'd like to take some time to read the names some of the people killed um naar Muhammad abua who is Zer years old a female abin ala who's Z years old young boy Amal Muhammad mu AB Z years old Yas Salah Yas Alo 0 years old carel Allah hamdan 0 years old Misa diab mmud alafa 0 years old Muhammad Nasser aad 0 years old Kanan Shadi Hashim Musta 0 years old anir Ahmed Muhammad Z years old abin elham Ahmed hammad

Juan Garcia: the minutes negate a sentence the recording does not (“not”)

Says something different

Both records carry the same sentence, but they disagree on a number or on whether it was negative. The same sentence appears in both records, but the minutes contain “not” where the recording has no negation. Around: “the stakes this year could not be higher and the choice”.

What the minutes say

Juan Garcia, Member of the Public said in a stunning display of disrespect of the democratic process the Democratic Party of Dona Ana in my opinion forted the will of the people of the 53rd House District. After Hill’s primary victory with 58% of the vote and leaving Madrid with 42%, Hill’s tragic passing on August 16th should have automatically elevated Madrid as the rightful successor. This is what respect for the voters and common sense would dictate in a true democracy but that is not what happened. Instead, a secretive group of seven unidentified party insiders orchestrated a backroom deal driven by ideological bias they rejected the centrist democrat chosen by the people and handpicked a person that never ran in the primary. This handpicked candidate who received zero votes from the community failed to submit financial disclosure forms on time yet in the eyes of this party elite this glaring lack of accountability means nothing. What matters most to them is ramming their own preferred candidate down the throats of the voter and now they have the audacity to suggest that this subversion of democracy represents “the will of the people”. This is a shameful affront. The principle

What the recording says

alwan 72 killed by Israel in genocide basma abdin Muhammad abush 51 years old killed by Israel in genocide Naser melah madin aluh 65 years old killed in genocide Hassan Ali Hassan bin s 70 years old killed by Israel in genocide musas abadis Miz alasi 72 years old killed in genocide yah Muhammed alar 82 years old killed in genocide Fatima Muhammed ham J 66 years old killed in genocide May these May these names echo in your memories may you see them when you sleep at night long live Palestine Viva Palestina mayor council Juan Garcia in a stunning display of disrespect for the Democratic process the Democratic party of donana in my opinion thed the will of the people of the 53rd house district

Hear it at 1:00:34Speaker as recorded: Juan Garcia3 PUBLIC PARTICIPATION 3.1 D

“harassment” is said 1× on the recording and never appears in the minutes

Word never written down

A word with legal, financial or health weight was said aloud and never written down. A word that carries legal, financial or health weight was spoken during the meeting but is absent from the written record of it.

What the minutes say

Nothing — this passage is absent from the minutes.

What the recording says

look at the changes that happened across the United States when it comes to our Wildland Urban interface possible insurance rates major catastrophes like the hurricane that just went through the Florida Panhandle area there's another one that's uh coming in the next few days our environment is changing our insurance rates are going to

~260 words of the recording have no counterpart in the minutes

Missing from the minutes

This part of the meeting left no trace in the written record. This stretch of the meeting is not reflected anywhere in the written record. Some gaps are legitimate — recesses, or a presentation summarised in one line. Others are discussion that simply did not make it in.

What the minutes say

Nothing — this passage is absent from the minutes.

What the recording says

I'm a friendly girl who's ready to still your heart at just 2 years old I'm at the perfect age to be your loyal companion and best friend I'm up for trying a cuddle session or some gentle play time if you're looking for a loving and affectionate companion to brighten your days I'm here waiting for you uh the dog of the week is love uh her number is 7289 4 if you would like to look her up on our website I'm a spirited pup who just celebrated

“liability” is said 1× on the recording and never appears in the minutes

Word never written down

A word with legal, financial or health weight was said aloud and never written down. A word that carries legal, financial or health weight was spoken during the meeting but is absent from the written record of it.

What the minutes say

Nothing — this passage is absent from the minutes.

What the recording says

and your values you must act do you feel safe with the surging violent crime are you comfortable with your son or daughter making a life-altering decision at one of the life terminating SL gender reassignment centers better known as abortion clinics where babies with no names are terminated does the idea of your hard-earned

~260 words of the recording have no counterpart in the minutes

Missing from the minutes

This part of the meeting left no trace in the written record. This stretch of the meeting is not reflected anywhere in the written record. Some gaps are legitimate — recesses, or a presentation summarised in one line. Others are discussion that simply did not make it in. It contains: “resign”.

What the minutes say

Nothing — this passage is absent from the minutes.

What the recording says

e e e [Music] you're on good afternoon everyone welcome to city council today's Monday October 7th 2024 it's approximately 1 p.m. and uh we'll go head and get started if you please stand and join me in a moment of silence for all our military personnel and our veterans as well that have served and those active that are serving and for our police and fire that protect our city 247 365 days a year have you joined me in the Pledge of Allegiance I pledge allegiance to

~1170 words of the recording have no counterpart in the minutes

Missing from the minutes

This part of the meeting left no trace in the written record. This stretch of the meeting is not reflected anywhere in the written record. Some gaps are legitimate — recesses, or a presentation summarised in one line. Others are discussion that simply did not make it in. It contains: “litigation”, “harassment”, “contamination”, “condemnation”, “displaced”.

What the minutes say

Nothing — this passage is absent from the minutes.

What the recording says

a few words on on fire prevention and safety uh smoke alarms and smoke detectors are the first step in protecting your family there's many things that we can do from the construction of our homes and the safety features that are now available and affordable that will protect our community when we look at the changes that happened across the United States when it comes to our Wildland Urban interface possible insurance rates major catastrophes like the hurricane that just went through the Florida Panhandle area there's another one

“Donna Striker Um” introduces themselves on the recording and is not named in the minutes

Speaker not named

Someone gave their name on the recording and is nowhere in the minutes. Someone identified themselves by name during the meeting — usually a member of the public taking the microphone — but that name appears nowhere in the written record. Caption spellings of names are unreliable, so confirm against the recording before relying on this.

What the minutes say

Nothing — this passage is absent from the minutes.

What the recording says

or items on the non-consent agenda Katrina will assist on individuals coming up to speak good afternoon my name is Donna Striker um the legislative session in Santa Fe in January of 2025 is going to be another opportunity important opportunity for the city of lausus and know that this year we had new council members a new mayor and

Hear it at 42:15Speaker as recorded: Donna Striker Um

“Gage Bernett Uh” introduces themselves on the recording and is not named in the minutes

Speaker not named

Someone gave their name on the recording and is nowhere in the minutes. Someone identified themselves by name during the meeting — usually a member of the public taking the microphone — but that name appears nowhere in the written record. Caption spellings of names are unreliable, so confirm against the recording before relying on this.

What the minutes say

Nothing — this passage is absent from the minutes.

What the recording says

know tell me call me email me think everybody has my number thank you uh good afternoon my name is Gage Bernett uh I've been a resident here and Los crues for roughly the past 3 years and today is October 7th 2024 marking the 1-year anniversary of the ongoing genocide taking place in Gaza I want to remind this

Hear it at 45:52Speaker as recorded: Gage Bernett Uh

“Alexander Burning I'll” introduces themselves on the recording and is not named in the minutes

Speaker not named

Someone gave their name on the recording and is nowhere in the minutes. Someone identified themselves by name during the meeting — usually a member of the public taking the microphone — but that name appears nowhere in the written record. Caption spellings of names are unreliable, so confirm against the recording before relying on this.

What the minutes say

Nothing — this passage is absent from the minutes.

What the recording says

years old Muhammad tuik Hassan abaka 48 years old Amil YF Muhammad Adam 50 years old hello my name is Alexander burning I'll be continuing reading the list of some of the estimated hundreds of thousands of Palestinians killed in the past year to a council that voted to take a ceasefire resolution off the agenda on May Thea Hussein

Hear it at 54:44Speaker as recorded: Alexander Burning I'll

“Yovani Sasan Ernandez” introduces themselves on the recording and is not named in the minutes

Speaker not named

Someone gave their name on the recording and is nowhere in the minutes. Someone identified themselves by name during the meeting — usually a member of the public taking the microphone — but that name appears nowhere in the written record. Caption spellings of names are unreliable, so confirm against the recording before relying on this.

What the minutes say

Nothing — this passage is absent from the minutes.

What the recording says

MIT alhaji 68 years old zadan Abdul Akisha 60 years old thank you hello mayor city council my name is yovani sasan ernandez mar Enriquez councelor McClair councelor matis councelor Graham councelor Flores on May 6 you all voted to remove a ceasefire resolution from Las crus City council's agenda with your vote you very clearly cided with Zionism with

Hear it at 58:10Speaker as recorded: Yovani Sasan Ernandez

“Uh Rick Renault” introduces themselves on the recording and is not named in the minutes

Speaker not named

Someone gave their name on the recording and is nowhere in the minutes. Someone identified themselves by name during the meeting — usually a member of the public taking the microphone — but that name appears nowhere in the written record. Caption spellings of names are unreliable, so confirm against the recording before relying on this.

What the minutes say

Nothing — this passage is absent from the minutes.

What the recording says

out to say thank you and please continue to support Community of Hope [Applause] all right U my name is uh Rick Renault lifelong Los cus resident I'm here to talk about NMSU there was an article in the newsbreak entitled Los C's parents called call for end to NMSU president search 19th September 2024 18 days ago it's

Hear it at 1:23:42Speaker as recorded: Uh Rick Renault

~650 words of the recording have no counterpart in the minutes

Missing from the minutes

This part of the meeting left no trace in the written record. This stretch of the meeting is not reflected anywhere in the written record. Some gaps are legitimate — recesses, or a presentation summarised in one line. Others are discussion that simply did not make it in. It contains: “falsify”, “asbestos”, “cancer”, “deportation”.

What the minutes say

Nothing — this passage is absent from the minutes.

What the recording says

life department and I'm here today to present the City Art board's recommendation from public art at the East Mesa Public Recreation Complex and this is Melanie Brown she is our City Art board Vice chair she's had a lot of different titles the new Recreation Complex is located off of Sona Springs Avenue at Sona Ranch Boulevard the overhead photo um shows where the art Sculpture Park is planned and the landscape site plan shows where the artwork will be approximately located which is here in that yellow dot

~390 words of the recording have no counterpart in the minutes

Missing from the minutes

This part of the meeting left no trace in the written record. This stretch of the meeting is not reflected anywhere in the written record. Some gaps are legitimate — recesses, or a presentation summarised in one line. Others are discussion that simply did not make it in. It contains: “immigration”, “deportation”.

What the minutes say

Nothing — this passage is absent from the minutes.

What the recording says

tool based not only on their Concepts but also in the scope of their work the City Art board agreed and approved the the recommendation both artists have agreed to be considered for the for these projects the project criteria for the fire station projects is one reflects the ethos of the firefighting Community two activates the exterior public space and streetcap and three resonates with the general public neighborhood and the fire station staff the first project is Fire Station 1 which is located across the street at 2011

~260 words of the recording have no counterpart in the minutes

Missing from the minutes

This part of the meeting left no trace in the written record. This stretch of the meeting is not reflected anywhere in the written record. Some gaps are legitimate — recesses, or a presentation summarised in one line. Others are discussion that simply did not make it in. It contains: “deportation”.

What the minutes say

Nothing — this passage is absent from the minutes.

What the recording says

laid out AC in the resolution a meeting was called to have discussion where AG Tores from the state of New Mexico um mayor protim Beno and I had gone to that meeting and He was discussing and he was just asking for some help and he was kind enough to actually give myself and the attorne um a meeting with him up in his office in Albuquerque and we kind of went through that a little bit further and came back and wrote this specifically for you all to

~650 words of the recording have no counterpart in the minutes

Missing from the minutes

This part of the meeting left no trace in the written record. This stretch of the meeting is not reflected anywhere in the written record. Some gaps are legitimate — recesses, or a presentation summarised in one line. Others are discussion that simply did not make it in. It contains: “racist”, “contamination”, “cancer”, “condemnation”.

What the minutes say

Nothing — this passage is absent from the minutes.

What the recording says

the monitoring well if we could go ahead and cap that so that we could go ahead and put in the newer pool in the Aquatic Center EPA concurred but they said okay but if we want another monitoring well or Wells you're going to install them and we said okay well lo and behold in the report um EPA started looking at that and they said you know there's kind of a an area that is missing some information and if you look at the at the map here

Were you there?

If the machine got something wrong, or if you can say what was actually said, put it on the record. Submissions are reviewed before they appear.