[Music] good morning everybody Welcome to the Animal Services board meeting it's October 26 2023 10 a.m. some of us have been here since 9: like me who don't remember things very well these days but I'd like to call the um the meeting um to order um Becky do you want to establish a quorum please Madam chair did you want to do the Pledge of Allegiance yeah we should I'm sorry we should will you please stand so we can recite the Pledge of Allegiance United States of AM stand and jice okay Becky board member de here we're trying to establish Quorum here thank you Bo member Ward there it goes it's on present thank you board member Flores I'm here on time surprise confetti time board member Karan here board member shayo Hernandez here and Cher Ganda here yes we have a quorum great we have a quorum okay I need a motion to accept the agenda so moved second by Flores motion made by um board member Sal Joel Hernandez second by um board member Flores Becky board member Ward yes yes board member Flores yes board member Karan yes board member shayo Hernandez yes chair gondala yes motion passes okay next up we have the minutes for approval um the September 20 2023 minutes hopefully people had an opportunity to read those can I get a motion to approve the minutes so moved motion made by Hernandez second by board member Corin Becky board member Warden yes board member Flores yes board member Ken yes board member shayo Hernandez yes chair gandera yes motion passes thank you Becky next up is our reports and presentations um there were a couple of us here at 9ine and one was um Michelle um from snap and she is unable to stay so she sends her um regrets and we'll get her um probably next month on so that she can report out for snap um so next up is our city county acos and did you flip or arm wrestle who is okay hi you must have won the arm wrestling no yeah okay supervisor says yes from City okay hello uh board members my name is Brian Hy I'm the case worker for Don County animal control here to present the September um report okay for the month of September we had 304 reported stray animals um out of the reported Strays we were able to pick up 245 stray animals um out of those animals 88 were cats and 157 dogs um we picked up four sick and injured animals it was two cats and two dogs uh we had 12 owner surrenders for the month of September and they were all dogs here's our reported stray animal calls comparison for um the last four years and here's our four-year um field return to owner um and that's if they find the animals um out in the field they're able to return them to the owners without having to take them to the Animal Service Center or our cour hold facility or wherever um for the month of September we had 29 and these are additional animals picked up we had zero owner surrendered cats we had 12 owner surrender dogs we had four sick and injured we had six welfare holds um for those of you that are new or don't remember welfare holds are for if border patrol or Sheriff's or Las Cruz's PD or anybody um arrests someone or detains anybody um and they have animals they and they're in the county we go and pick them up and do a welf for hold um we had no neglector cruelty cases for that month uh we had five shelter quarantines we had one home quarantine uh we had four courth hold quarantine um cases um we have two animals currently being held at our facility um shortly those two will be um taken out one was resolved by court and the other one's a quarantine um we had zero rabes submissions uh we had 36 diverted intakes for the month of September we had 462 education um it's probably a little higher than that uh because we participated in the fair uh we had a booth out there so we were doing education Outreach while we were there um but it wasn't really easy to quantify how much educ we did while we were there um and then I participated in some middle schools um I did a presentation for um snake ID and um how to basically not get bit by snakes uh for the kids um and that was um for one school but they were going to distribute it amongst all the elementary schools that they had so that was some more education um for the month of September we had 775 total calls and this is broken down by each district um in district one we had zero cats and six dogs District Two we had 31 cats and eight dogs in District three we had six cats and 29 dogs District Four we had 14 cats and 23 dogs um District 5 was a hot one for us for this month for September and that was probably because we had our Aces project at that going on at that time so we were more involved in in that area uh we had 26 cats and 34 dogs picked up and district 6 we had zero cats and 18 dogs and in district 7 um usually about every other month that's usually our hot district and we had 11 cats and 39 dogs and these are our street cats picked up by District these are our straight dogs picked up by District um like I said District s and District Five are hot ones for this for September um it kind of alternates between those two don't ask me why that's just how it happens and these are reasons for our owner releases um so we had two animals um that they were unable to keep on the property and they didn't want to get citations um we had four that were um they just weren't able to take care of them we had one for aggressive uh we had uh two that the um they were just unable to control the animals uh we had two that were sick and injured and we had one owner that was moving out the state and didn't want to take the dog and for that I stand for any questions thank you Brian any questions see none we appreciate you so much and all your work please extend our gratitude to the officers and yourself yes ma'am hello good morning Madam chair members of the board my name is Gino himz I the animal control supervisor for the city there we go I am going to present to you our September numbers so for the month of September we responded to 538 stray calls of those 229 were Goa we were able to apprehend 309 of those uh 250 were impounded at this an service center 158 were dogs and 92 were cats we were successful in field ring 59 animals out in the field which meant means that those animals never crossed the threshold of the Animal Service Center uh we were unsuccessful in field ring 29 of those and of those they had some sort of identification however for some reason they weren't able to give them back to the owner so we had a total of 88 identifiable animals our next slide is our reported stray graph again we responded to 538 Strays bring us to a grand total for the year of 4,605 and as I've reported before this is the number one Peak Performance goal that we have um it says that we will uh attempt to secure 65% of all Strays for last month we were successful in 62% so a few months ago I rep reported that we did reach that 65 goal 65% goal um slowly but surely we're going back to our normal numbers next is our three-year field RTO comparison again we field RTO 59 animals bringing us to a total of 417 for the year um this is our number two Peak Performance goal of 25% of Strays being secured and returned back to the owner last month we achieved 14 per .5 here's a graph for our community C program we responded to 65 cats and traps of those 13 were uh Community cats so they were released out in the field so for a grand total of 591 cats and traps for the year and we were able to s or release um 109 of those back in the field that's about an 18% uh of our calls of 18% of the cats and traps are being released back here's a reason for owner relasing animals five puppies unable to care for five dogs unable to care for five dogs with parvo four dogs with health issues four dogs cannot keep in the yard keep escaping three dogs for Dangerous Dog admission three cats um new location does not allow animals three dogs for aggression two dogs um the new place does not allow two dogs were too many animals and one dog killed another of their family pets the reasons that we were unable to fill RTO 23 there was no contact by phone or at the residence three owners were out of town two chips were not up registered and one chip was not updated the previous owner was in El Paso and the new owner was unknown and finally here is our excuse me here is our last two measures for a preep performance uh number three is temp per reduction in stray animal bites we were able to not able to but there was a 22.8% increase in strayan bites from September of 22 to September of 23 number four is a 10% reduction in owner victim bites which was actually a 10.8 increase in owner victim bites we had 77 uh so far for 2023 and we had 66 for 2022 so our monthly calls for service this month was 1,141 bringing us to a total of 10,640 for the year some highlights for last month all the acos are now NAA 1 and NAA 2 certified I was able to obtain some scholarships for them for the animal protection of New Mexico and every one of my acos receiv received those scholarships but there was a timeline that they had to meet and September October 1st was that deadline so all the acos were able to meet that and now they're all certified with that because of that um we had 175 hours of training that included their NAA training and some of the city required training as well oh NAA stands for the national animal Control Association sorry about that you know um what kind of training does it entail would be helpful there are many many Madam chair there are many many topics I think um so each level has at least 12 topics and we're looking at everything from uh blood Sports dog fighting and fighting care and maintenance shelter operations impounding animal identification exotic animal investigations um those are just the ones off the top of my head uh photographing crime scenes um anyone that comes to mind there I think in both levels there's something like 36 different topics was pretty detailed yeah yeah maybe a presentation next month regarding that sure would be helpful councelor Flores is that you with your light on oh no no no sorry you have your light on you want to say something I I did I did if that's all right I actually have a comment I wanted to comment on the animal controls on the county side um before Gino went up so I apologize Gino um in the animal Don and County Animal Control on the Asus project as everybody knows the Asus stands for animal control and code enforcement environmental survey and those projects are going very strongly and they have started up again as we used to do for years years before that um just to give you a report on because those projects are inconsistent with cleanup days where we go into those rural areas and we provide resources for those constituents in those areas and the rolloffs and other resources that come into those areas so the those individuals can clean up their areas instead of that trash ending up in our desert it ends up in our dumpsters and it makes it so much easier for everyone so since the beginning of these cleanup with Carlos days we have picked up with animal control because it's it's a partnership with animal control and code enforcement and planning and zoning we're not picking up the trash we go in and provide the roll offs into the community we alert them of the violations that we see and then we give them time to clean up that Community we bring those rooll offs in that Community they dump their own trash and clean up their own Community that's the trash that's reported that's being dumped out when we when we do those weight tickets great thank you so much thank you so much and all of that is being paid for out of out of the um El Camino Real the IDP partnership so it's not coming directly out of General funds wow thank you so much officer thank you counc lce yes and I had a question for you Gino yes ma'am um I'm sorry but um I think it was about um let me try to yeah if you could just maybe I'll get a [Music] no it'll probably come you know like at midnight I'll think about it oh I know um all the calls that you get you get thousands of calls right yes ma'am who surfaces the phones I mean how how is that managed it just seems like you know a ton of uh calls a day yes Madam chair uh board member FLOTUS the majority of our calls come through central dispatch um secondary would be uh citizens calling our office directly and then third would be uh self-initiated calls for the officers they see a violation and they start their own card on that and then finally way way down on the list would probably be me when I get an email or a phone call from a citizen that has some concerns um I'll uh explain to them our process and then if um they still wish to speak to an officer I'll create a call myself for the officers to respond to so there's numerous ways that they can uh a register complaint and uh central dispatch U how is that uh the personnel there uh I'm just it just seems like so many calls I mean in a given month um yes ma'am and so do we do we have the staff uh the Personnel to uh take to weather all those calls uh madam uh board member Flores I understand that as usual even mvda is short hand short staffed oh sure sure um but they do have call tickers and they have dispatchers and at any given point those can um cross train um but their man 24/7 and I'm sure that they could always use more help I just don't know their their numbers or their Staffing oh okay that that that's out of your yes yeah jurisdiction of uh whatever oversight but okay I was just wondering because it's just so enormous and there's always shortages here and there yes um so but we've never heard of any have we um mayor protm I mean we've never received directly any information about shortages in that regard or councelor fles um board member fles we have MDA has come to speak specifically to counil related a few months ago I'm wondering if but adamal control no wda came and spoke to um the calls that they receive and sort of the capacity that they have and and as a part of the conversation specific to budget if you recall before in in June or so okay because that was going to be my question for Leanne um do we get uh do we have a line item for that should I know that if I don't I apologize Madam chair board member floors at just like the Animal Service Center MDA is one we're the Fiscal Agent for Murda so we do deliver their financials for them uh we do all of their procurement um I do know just like other departments within the city they do have staffing issues as well um but um as far as I think the director or executive director Hugo costus came and gave a presentation I think actually uh board chair it was around probably before May when we adopted the budget which probably I think want to say March or April and we'll probably do it again this year as well at one of the work sessions for the budget have him come in and give his so um I we do I mean our finance does attend their their board meetings but as far as the operations I think um commissioner Shannon is the lead on that that particular board so okay thank you so much Mr de I was just um yeah I was just curious as to how um how the monies are funnel to sustain these programs so thank you so much and thank you Madame chair supervisor am minus I wanted to ask since we brought up the um item around calls and the calls that are coming um into mvda and then being right um sent to you all um via some process do you keep track of animal cruelty I mean I know you do but animal cruelty as it relates to domestic violence because certainly there's an intersection and we're finding more and more right um um related to being a a a deep intersection between those two and what is your process like what is it how many of those calls were children are involved in that in in that anim animal cruelty TK what is your process by which you referring to other um entities to investigate that particularly um abuse and neglect right of children yes ma'am Madam chair uh luckily I had sent four officers to Albuquerque recently for that the the link between domestic violence and animal abuse I think it was in September I'm sorry I didn't put that up there on my slide now that you refreshed my memory um so with that our cruelty calls are really really minimal I mean I'm thinking for the month we are responding to maybe 46 just off the top of my head so once the officers respond to that call of course their their priority at that time is addressing the animal issue um should there be some sort of um domestic violence or child abuse child neglect what have you um they will refer it to the appropriate agency which could be LCPD adult Protective Services or Child Protective Services whichever they turn that part over to those who have a better education and understanding of what they're looking for but yes absolutely if we see anything that needs attention we will report it appropriately so I guess then my second question is how do we do we see um from the 40 plus calls more of an intersection where domestic violence is occurring um given the the investigation occurring and then how is it how is it being identified in the reporting of MDA and because I don't feel like and the reason I'm asking is because we do see an increase um I have a student intern that's working um specifically on a domestic violence prevention plan um many of our calls that go into um LCPD are DV related um and so I'm I'm Wonder wondering if if if there is a mechanism with mvda and what you're receiving and what you're collecting that we can really own in on because it just seems like it's an epidemic proportions in in my opinion and an only way to look at it is to have well data to support it and I don't think that we have a great mechanism in place no criticism of it's just the way we're collecting information and that you know that FBI is asking for certain certain things we may not be really getting to the Crux of the matter so I'm I'm wondering if if if we understand with the calls even though they're 40s something less than a they nowhere a percentage 1% of all the 11,000 calls you've received thus far but I'm I'm wondering if if maybe there's a different way to identify those calls Madam chair I think let me let me make an example out of those 46 that we respond to for last month um maybe the majority of those were for Animals left in cars at a mall at at Albertson at a retail store um so those took the majority of those calls the rest of them could have been labeled incorrectly which should have been maybe a care and maintenance more than a cruelty so then they weren't um titled correctly finally I think if if that number is something that really needs to be um given MDA would be the ones that have that appropriate number because then they would see that transfer from the cruelty call initially uh transferred over to Adult Protective Services or Child Protective Services whichever may be or the law enforcement that handles that jurisdiction thank you supervisor heis and Brian is shaking his head head yes yes yes so yeah Brian please please come up and clarify uh Madam chair um Comm so um I know for the donana county side um from what we see um as me used to be in an officer kind of know the in and outs of it um if it's a felony animal cruelty um it would be split from our card that we get called out to to a card for the sheriff's unit so they would actually split that card into two so that way they could track each side of it um and then if it's not a felony or like he said it could be mislabeled to a care maintenance something like that and we would change that but as far as um the county side um if it's anything that's involved into like a domestic and we get there um we would split it with our Sheriff's unit and they would go and do their side of it so it's it's actually it would show up on ours but it would show that that it would split to the Sheriff's unit thank you for the clarification I sorry oh yeah I I just actually have a followup about this because it's kind of an interesting councelor Corin and then I'm sorry Mary Lou do you want to clarify some more about this yeah I just wanted to add in like um officer um Hy was going to say in regards to that and probably Gino would probably agree with me once an animal control officer would be the first responder for an animal cruelty and they went in and started investigating and they decided they needed additional agencies on scene when they and they turned it over to LCPD or or the sheriff's department and maybe Child Protective Services or Adult Protective Services at that point they would start that through the central dispatch and they would add another agency and they would add multiple cards so they would split that what they call split the card out so when you research that in central dispatch it would go into two different agencies so we would have a have that on our statistics and then Doo or LCPD would would have that on their statistics as well in a separate separate um Reporting System you see what I'm saying I do I see what you're what you're getting at but I'm wondering if we're appropriately addressing really when there is animal cruelty and you just said like you sent your people to more training right to understand and then be able maybe to ask the questions I'm assuming um similarly to what we do at CYFD Protective Services right always learning improving the way we're interviewing folks getting to the Crux of the matter I'm wondering if just our system I'm wondering if it's under reported I guess is what I'm where I were because our system isn't equipped to handle like I'll give you an example domestic violence and juveniles when you see battery on a household Member One if it's not a top it's the second juvenile's are are um violent in households that isn't being captured in youth specifically juvenile specifically in our systems because there's no way to do that our system isn't capturing it so I'm thinking like visionwise are we capturing the right data specific to this and how are we getting to the Crux the root causes of that and maybe I'm going down to Rob I feel like I'm going down rabbit hole but I just want to make sure that we're capturing the data correctly and if we're not then conversations need to be have with MDA and others yeah Madam chair I think you're probably correct on that we probably does need to I mean I know it's being like I said the carts and whatnot are being splitted but in regards to being um whether it's um being reported you know appropriately um in regards to those statistics it's probably not the whole process the whole the whole um the whole um you know the process going around in regards to all the agencies the way it needs to be the reporting of that I I couldn't I couldn't answer for that but I I'm I'm sure it's probably falling short somewhere in there in regards to that so probably I would say maybe a task force going into there and looking at the whole the way things are getting reported into the 911 system and looking at that and seeing if that needs to be edited or whatnot into the mobile CAD thanks Mary thank you yes councilor Corin no I was just thinking about this in terms of like the way that we're thinking about it in terms of reporting but I also wonder if there's a place where we can do more so for instance if if the call is initiated by LCPD and it's domestic violence and that's the that's it does it go the other way that is does LCPD then call Animal Control consistently like if there's a child in a home typically I think they would call cfd regardless of whether or not the child's conditions seem hazardous or not I think and I wonder if something similar yeah something similar could be sort of part of a different kind of response to domestic violence in particular because it would be good to have an animal like someone who can really understand what the picture for the animals are and perhaps that's a place where you know there might be more evidence or there could be potential intervention I know that in many cases the issues that come from people people staying in those situations relate to their animals um and perhaps an intervention point for Education about what support there is like if you want to leave this is what could happen with your animals and it makes me think about our mental health response if we can have a similar thing that would be inclusive of animals for for intimate partner violence potentially that would be really cool so not really I guess it would add more work to y'all's schedule but it feels like it would be part of a comprehensive look at that I agree I agree yeah just been thinking a lot about about it U for a long time and particularly that I have a student that's working very specifically on this and I know working in the Child Welfare Arena that intersection you see it and when you talk about the data I mean the DV is that's happening in this community today it's enormous and I don't think people know that um and I'm starting to become more familiar with it just because it's sort of in my face um two or three times a week given my students um work um it's really challenging and so um you know when you think about the poverty that also we we have in this community and there's a lot of impact so I I like that comprehensive look and maybe understanding the referral process and what is happening and how are we capturing that data yes so Madam chair uh just a follow up to uh board member karan's uh comments while you were speaking one thing that came to my mind is that if any law enforcement agency responds to a domestic violence issue and they see a child with bruising or even uh a significant other with bruising that's an easy report that's easy to do you're not going to see bruising on a cat or a dog so we need to be more trained better trained to recognize that possible animal abuse as well well all of us are Mand mandated reporters you don't have to see a bruise when you see things like that it's a suspicion of child abuse and neglect and knowing what you know with the intersection between DV right and children and animal cruelty and those things that in my opinion should be an automatic call to CPS reporting right these are the things we found in this in the home this you know very concerned about it and and and even you don't have to have all the detail if you suspect you make the call absolutely thank you Gino I'm sorry to get into this a little more detail but I thought this is an awesome topic that like you I'm passionate about this one as well okay seeing any other thank you Gino you're welcome okay next up we have Clint couldn't get to good morning Clint faer executive director Animal Service Center msia Valley like to present to you the September numbers for the Animal Services Center uh currently there are 486 animals at the center this is um as of uh I believe Wednesday is when this was sent out so 397 dogs 89 cats so our intake continues to grow as you see here it's a total of 875 animals came into the center uh 564 dogs 304 cats and the comparison there you see that we are continuing to to go up and up this is how those animals came in uh again our biggest like usual and and as it should be is Strays by Animal Control uh 503 animals that's 57 a half% came from uh the Animal Control Officers the next one is Strays by the public and then the still staggering to me is the owner surrenders 11 a half% that came in so 101 animals so our returns there's 16 total as you can see there uh again we always try to help these individuals with what they stand in need of to be able to keep their animal if they want to keep them sometimes they just don't want to keep them and and we understand that uh and sometimes we are able to provide some food we're able to provide some vet care Etc that will allow them to stay our diverted intakes 151 uh divided intakes for those that are watching the first time are whenever an animal comes to the center and our front staff is able to have them not come into the center so whether like I said with giving them food if it's owner surrender or vet care or if it's a stray animal that somebody found will'll have them you know go back and contact some uh we'll give them the information they need to be able to post uh that the dog is lost will file a lost report or a found report then we'll be able to encourage them to walk around the neighborhood uh you know knock on doors if anybody knows the animals so those are all considered diverted intakes and these are how those animals that came in left uh the biggest one as you can see is that euthanasia we continuing to have to keep the population down and the next slide will show how what those youth and Ages were but we're committed to keep and and have our animals at a level our animal population a level that we can critically care for and that's our overall goal uh almost everything was down however adoptions or lower than it was last year at this time uh reclaims uh rescues was uh was a little bit lower they had higher number than last time barely but a lower percentage because we had more animals coming in in so we continue to have that fight September transfers 123 these are where those animals went to for the rescue groups um I did try to get one of our rescue coordinators Elizabeth seed here today so we could recognize her and all the hard work that they do but she flat out refused and said no she does not like public speaking nor appearing in public but she did say please mention my name and say what a great job we're doing so that's what I'm doing they're doing a fantastic job we appreciate all that they do um Liz and also Amy is the other one Amy's off for the week or else I could have gotten her and then we have another one filling in that's being cross trained her name's Kim and she does a fantastic job as well they are driving back from Phoenix today after a big uh drop off of animals occurred there with our halo transport Partners so we're very thankful for that so here's the euthanasia reasons as you can see the number one reason again is space medical you can imagine whenever whenever there's a space next to something that means that we needed to uh euthanize and we euthanize for a medical reason but if we had the space we would have kept it and held on to it so the reason with these the Medicals are so hard is we have a dedicated team of um ones that uh dedicated their career to saving animals and making them healthy and they just don't have the space for it and that's hard for my co-workers that dedicate that time however we're we're continually increased or we're continually looking forward to the new center opening because that will allow the existing Center to be able to be a medical facility uh however that does not increase the number of people that I have that can care for for it so even though we're going to have more room and we may even have some empty kennels we're going to rely on see if we can get volunteers see if we can get uh Community workers that already we we already have those but see if we can continue to get those to help with other things and that will relieve time that our Medical Department Can Help the Animals As best we can here's our surgical Department uh amazing work that they do 3 162 surgeries and you can see there uh the I don't know what color that is aqua color is for September you can see we did a lot of TNR surgeries that were coming in a little low on adoptions uh however the shelter Foster and other continue to make up for that they just do a fantastic job other is anything besides those three that you see there TNR adoption and shelter Foster is what other stands for total of 603 hours for our volunteers amazing work they have been so busy going out to the public a lot of times we have uh like they just went to White Sands and it was it was an information booth is what it was and that's where we utilize our volunteers quite a bit that means that we do not have to have a staff person there so we are going out in a lot more different places so it's just an information table volunteers do a fantastic job of housing those and getting the information out of what we're doing also of note our volunteer program has been selected by mty's fund they're a major player in the animal industry they've been selected to uh have our program evaluated so we're going to be sending questions out to our volunteers we vetted the questions uh just this week those questions will go out and we'll be able to there's questions like um of what qu what can you what would you like to see change in the volunteer program at the ascmv or how can we better make the program more or so just good information that we can glean from these vast amount of volunteers and hopefully we'll get good participation in that and grow the program from that our visitors visitors were down just just a little bit he ended the month at400 uh for the month of September our web page views went down as well uh to 32,900 almost 33,000 for our website Facebook went down a little bit uh Henry did not have another birthday so we had to drop a little bit from that but it continues to be the main source that we have and I think this reflects it how has a continual uptick of usage you see there all the way back uh in when we jumped way up in November of 22 it's just been kind of a steady increase all the way up uh we do fantastic we attended a training just this last Friday or Thursday I believe uh or Monday I'm sorry I think it was Monday of um by the city on how to properly use social media best ways to get the attention and individuals on there and also to make it more ADA Compliant so we're going to be working on that as well I learned that on ADA Compliant they have a system that reads the website for them but the that does not pick up images and so you have to use another process to be able to to do alt text and they can describe the image for it it was interesting some of our upcoming events that we have working with the fire department have adoptions at Firehouse 1 on November 4th we're going to be at the uh community resource fair and phry fair at NMSU on November 15th November 8th is the national adoption week we'll be partying hard on that week trying to get animals out as soon as we can and then on November 18th we're also going to be at the icebox Brewery which is a very popular one for my co-workers to go to uh they all enjoy you have to take uh you know rock paper scissors to see who goes that one but we all we love these events coming up um our volunteer department does a fantastic job Yoli is amazing in what she does and getting us out in the public and Milo was adopted pretty darn quick so our cat of the week was adopted we're excited for that and then mooki still waiting for forever friend and that's my presentation I'll answer any questions thank you Clint yes um board memb CIO Hernandez thank you madam chair um Clint I was wondering can you go back to the slide about the owner surrenders on the page the returns or the surrenders uh returns this one okay and then can you go to the owner surrenders so with the owner surrenders um does does that include those that are coming in just to the uh shelter itself that doesn't include what's coming in through Cruis or doniana correct um yeah that includes the subtype owner surrender so if they bring if acos bring one in it does conclude that all right so that includes everything cool all right thank you I just wanted to clarify that thank you board member yes Council cour M thank you Clint um I just have a couple quick questions one is you know you alluded to the staff I I understand you guys are doing a staff sort of position study um so I'm hoping that in the upcoming budget Year we will see some clear sort of Staffing up Staffing implications for for us to increase that um do do you feel like that will be part of what will come into our budget conversations well we're currently doing a compensation study is that what you're referring to uh no I'm looking I'm wondering about sort of the like position count how many people you have uh what what you would need going forward because I think since we're about to discuss budget and you identified a shortcoming I'd like to know if if you're going to have some numbers for us when we go to the budget process to to the best of my knowledge we don't have a center wide study like that going on right right now now we're not in part of one I do know that um we have our budget analyst and operations director which is Bernice they're working with one another to see what jobs can be switched over and shared uh with those two but as far as a a center wide program no we don't we're not currently in one to see if we have as many as we need uh but I can definitely look into one and we can can get one started uh I can tell you that we we did increase what we thought we needed to to house into a new center uh the challenge and that was last budget year we increased positions the challenge has been is keeping these positions filled uh one new position that we have that is is in the interview stage here shortly is staffing specialist and that's the one that we requested for this last budget year that will be immensely helpful I've already discussed with HR and how that's going to be helpful uh to move the process along a lot smoother uh right now we are it's hard to get communication through HR just for the means that they are slammed every department needs hiring every department needs the the the process to move forward and so everybody's calling and saying please do this please do this and it only slows the process down when we submit something that may not be complete like like there's a hiring packet and if that's not all complete everything filled out correctly everything grinds to a halt get the request the information I mean it can you know sometimes take three three or 4 days to get the information back but with the staffing specialist we can have all that information put together and then sent um they'll be able the staffing specialist will be able to do appointments for the the tours and it's just going to be a lot smoother operation and hopefully fill those a lot more quickly so the issue is not that you aren't budgeted for the staff to have both things functional it's that they you just don't have those staff I would say uh in my opinion we need more staff because of the issue of staying full staff does that make sense okay so I I guess what I'm suggesting or very strongly suggesting is that you have a clear picture of this when you submit your budget and what those staff positions are and uh what's needed to be able to increase that capacity so that's I guess what I'm asking for you to follow up on yeah and there is a mechanism that says especially the New Mexico State law and the but there suggestions that state that each hour or each animal has a certain amount of time that they are Touched by an individual or cared for and so if we go by that uh then we can get some solid information for you sir thank you yeah that would be good because I think it's important to us as we consider the budget and that we have really clear picture of what positions you're requesting ing in the upcoming budget cycle so um the other question I just have and I'm sure this will come through the facilities is that is there a a time for you guys to be opening or transitioning uh there's nothing set however there is a request for completion date on our part we've requested that things be solidified and completed uh the second week of November so we can get in there we have a community uh Community Day of unity I'm sorry I forgot what the name of it was but it's November 18th and it's going to be there at the facility kind of a soft opening kind of a thing where we have people come in we'll uh they can see the dogs and the adoptions the only thing that needs to be completed are the Landscaping in the cement areas the cement get acquainted areas the cement has been poured so all the all all the areas have been poured Bo so now we're just waiting for rock to be put in and they were doing that yesterday uh I do I do know that he said they need more rock to come in and fencing completed in our playards for those to be completed but we can get in without those being completed so we're really close super close the thing on the 18th is actually my community meeting so that's uh partly why I was asking because I didn't want to put something on you just before we officially make that I don't want to put it on you all when you have a lot of other things going or if that wouldn't fit with your timeline but if you feel like that's still that's doable um then okay I will Yeah we actually had an excellent talk uh yesterday a group meeting about it and uh we feel strongly that we'll okay be by the 18th okay if not we have a b plan okay awesome just checking and that'll be exciting I think so thank you those are all that's all the questions I have thanks thank you board member ACC Corin board member fles thank you Madame chair chair and thank you um board member Coran for bringing up the budget issue um and Leanne isn't this about the time uh every Department should be looking at what they're really going to be needing for the next fiscal year um board chair board member Flores we have started we're going to be doing a kickoff doing training for the forms all of those dates I want to say are in November around the 1 of November yeah I'm looking at Rosio because they did put out the calendar and they're going to be meeting with each individual department and I'm sure Clint is on our list to meet with with each you know to be one of those like departments as well and so yes we're we're already doing forecasting for the revenue and trying to U meet with Mr peely and trying to to finalize everything so that way we can uh open up our Erp and start everybody entering in so that way we can meet with C the council and have our budget um Retreat right in February yes hopefully three days from8 to five so um Leanne how would Clint be working with Joe or is it Joe is still here right in uh HR yeah nature yes yes how would Clint be working with Joe to assure that um there's budgeting um you know that the correct budgeting staff budgeting is um is discussed met and hopefully filled because it's it's a process and everything is time time time and and U and timeliness too so um does Clint speak directly with Joe and then Joe speaks to you or EO or if I could I this is a process that we've done in the past um I don't think it's changed but there's forms for that in the budget preparation so we would fill out those forms and then and I'd also have discussions with my HR representative uh who's Veronica no who's it boola is the one I was thinking of so we'll speak with Oola and we'll be able to um have that discussion if if after that form goes then they usually contact me and we have a discussion about they being HR contacts me we have a discussion about the form and it just moves through that process okay and then um that process um that process moves slowly doesn't it or does it and well it does it move at all because sometimes I I wonder um so um I I'm just looking at um wanting a good outcome in so far as you know the center being um fully staffed and I I understand that we have Monumental vacancies in the city I I I think they're Monumental in my humble opinion um we we have so many vacancies Here There and Everywhere and then I'm I'm sitting thinking um well sometimes even standing up I'm thinking I'm thinking how are we going to fill those vacancies and what um what should we be doing to assure that you know and I'm saying this because our um we have crucial people here uh Miss lean and um so I just um I just want to make sure that you're able to communicate clearly with HR and that HR is able to uh you know provide the needs for the for the for the service center and uh so yeah thank you Clint thank you and thank you MRH thank you Madame chair thank you board member Flores Clint you have any other no ma'am okay thank you hi good morning Finance right yes Finance my name is Veronica yoa good morning good morning um I'm with I'm an accountant one on behalf of the finance department I'll be going over the uh un audited financial statements for the end of September okay [Music] and I'm working on the breathing right um starting with the statement of net position highlights we have our our cash that is at 1, [Music] 373,000 25 we then offset that with our liabilities which is at [Music] $23,170 following that we have our revenues collected in advance and those are at 27,600 and our total liabilities and fund balance is at 1,373 25 moving forward we go on to our change in net position our total revenues for the end of September were 1,559 240 and then our total expenditures were at 827,000 our budget to actual and change in net position again we went over our total revenue which is at 1,559 240 um bringing our our budget our budget budget parameter is at 25% I didn't mention that um So based on that it's at 33.4% our total expenditures are again at 827,000 three and that's at 17.4% of the budget um bringing our net change to 73183 our revenues in expenditures um throughout the period there is a decrease in revenues and that is due to the cities and counties contribution that was at 36.2% and that was on the previous slide um you'll also notice a slight decreases in services and that's just due to the nature of expenditures [Music] um so moving on again we're reviewing our expenditures our year-to-date expenditures were at 827,000 of that the total made up of salary was 59% our benefits were at 20% services at 10% supplies at 7% other is at 1% and then insurance is at 2% all the other Capital repairs and maintenance and temp services are at zero and with that all stand for any questions thank you so much any questions see none all right can we have one more little slide okay these are the pets of the accounting department um so these are our little friendlies noodles was actually um a found and she had like a broken jaw so my coworker got her all fixed up a thank you so are all these adopted from the center or like pets that have pets that have been found or things of that nature I mine is the little one Bella at White Sands and I adopted her so but so thank you to all the staff for doing it it's so cute so thank you thank you okay um next up is our executive uh committee chair um report and um what was discussed um and was obviously the agenda but there is some conversation about um the 501c3 I think we'll be talking more about that um here shortly um there was um discussion of the jpa approval um and also since we're going to be moving we hope to quarterly meetings having Clint participate in those meetings when there are agenda items specific um to animals am I no oh I messed it up here comes Clinton to correct me Clint AER executive director the so the the meetings part was is for me to go to the commission meetings and the council meetings that occur with the City and the and so whenever there is a animal topic isn't that what I said you said the the quarter meetings for the board oh got you I and I mean I can attend those when there's ever there's a animal related one if you want me to but I think I'll be to everyone actually so that's the only difference okay thanks thank you any questions on that no okay see none um facilities I'm going to turn it over to Chris yes Madam chair thank you uh the facilities the facilities uh committee met on October 5th at the new facility thank you for Clint for that wonderful uh tour we got um as Clint already said they did pour uh the pads in the meet and greet area so that was done the poles were being cemented in while we were walking around the facility um the puppy cages are in there was issues with the trim not aligning with the top of the wall and I believe that they have those on order so those are good to go um the wireless wires have been installed for the routers have we gotten any update on that or are we still waiting on routers to be put in wireless routers wireless routers for the wires for the wireless routers thank you yeah so it's all been wired and we're still waiting for the hardware it's on back order perfect so we're and the trim is being currently installed around those puppy cages as we're speaking yep like as I say this as you're saying that they're using their drill it's because of magical um cat kennels are under production no shipping dates or do we have a shipping date yet we do we just found out last meeting which was the on Tuesday that they are going to arrive the week of November 6th perfect okay awesome there is some they sent a quote for us to purchase remember we wanted to purchase or I wanted to purchase the ones that we currently have but there's a quote where they want to charge me $30,000 for another just to buy 24 walls cuz remember they're all stacked together and so that wall is shared by two cages so I need another wall if I want them to be separate so but they charged they they did some like they're trying to make up for the price of the discounted one with the with the walls and they so I got to go look at the the the existing cages and see if we need all the hardware there're saying we need or if we can just you know go without it so but I think that's ridiculous for $30,000 for 24 walls that's that's a lot and that that jumps the price all the way up it's um to 90,000 almost $9,000 and I can't I can't do that got it did we have any updates on the key cards that will work at both facilities they're waiting for I talked to them um and they're waiting they being facilities is waiting for a PO to be generated for to purchase new cards that they think might work might work okay yeah waiting on a PO for cards that might work might okay um cameras are all set up and running uh exception is in the the kennel rooms have those been put in yet and running or no not yet not yet not yet okay they're all installed we're just waiting for the connections to be made perfect for that got it okay and then the dishwasher arrived and it is installed are we still waiting on quotes so we got quotes for because let me back up they have to be installed by a licensed electrician and a licensed plumber or avoids the warranty so we got quotes for those to be done uh they require because of the intense Heat that these commercial dishwashers generate that has to have special Parts it can't just use regular Pipe PVC pipe to go down into the drain so we are they're waiting for parts once those come in the plumbers will install their plumbing parts and then the electrician and then move the the the dishwasher in and then the uh electrician will make their connections and they're going to do both of them at the same time the one of the new and the one at the old yes sir cool perfect and that was all Madam chair thank you any questions okay see none um we are now at the discussion items and we have an overview of 501c3 status Clint you want to do some introductions and move us along on this agenda item thank you yes there it is so joining with me today up at the Das is uh Benjamin he is the attorney for the ascmv and uh we've had quite a few discussions about this on the over the phone and in person but first I wanted to give you a little bit of some quick facts of how this occurred uh and and why this occurred so back in May Kelly Barker reached out to me saying that the Humane Society of Southern New Mexico is going to be disbanded and she want she asked me flat out if I would be interested in taking over that 501c3 designation instead of starting one from scratch and if we are interested then she would make plans to touch Bas with uh Mr Bryce who's the executive director of the main society southern New Mexico I said we were interested and I would like to see some information so May 8th uh she contacted Mr Bryce Mr Bryce agreed to it he was in support of uh the asmv taking that over he understood that the Humane Society in Southern New Mexico would be no more uh and Miss Barker was really uh adamant that something happened to to be able to hold on to that Legacy of what the Humane Society of New Mex southern New Mexico has done through these years they've microchipped and Prov provided chip scanning just they've done a lot of great work so we do want to be able to uh hold on to that Legacy as much as we can and recognize for that that work May 31st I was notified by Miss Barker that at that time all of any of the remaining uh board members from the heing Society of sou Mexico had resigned so that kind of threw a monkey in the wrench of like just like we do here we would meet as a board and say okay we're going to dissolve and here's what we're going to do with everything well they didn't have a board they only had an executive director so with communication with our attorney uh in June we were able to get a resolution started and and drafting one out that says that Mr Bryce has that in the meantime back in June uh of 2023 and June and July our attorney got in touch with the uh it would be the accountant for Humane Society of sou New Mexico because we wanted to be sure that everything was in good standing and it was they did a fantastic job in all the books that they held there was money in the account uh and all the filing to the IRS was current so everything was a good standing so that was excellent news so on September 11th the the uh resolution was sent to Mr Bryce and he returned it and signed on September 28th if you remember that is about the time of our last board meeting when these discussions were happening and I'm like this this is all new stuff brand new stuff that we're discussing is just happening so we'll have more information for you so that's why we're here today for that uh I I do want to go over and this is uh something that I did really quick this morning is I said let's show the board the advantage of having a friends of the ascmv before we we get into it all I did was Google animal uh animal industry grants with nonprofits or 51 C3 and I had a whole page and I just grabbed five right off the top that I could do I mean ASPCA you all know it's a very popular name they give grants specifically cash grants specifically for nonprofits that we could look for Banfield Foundation you've heard of that one uh with the vaccines and their hospitals that they have so various it says right there various opportunities for 501c3's the give effect they like this one for software that can help uh non profit organizations be able to go paperless uh the gry muzzle organization specifically for senior pets so all these are things that we would not be able to go after as a a government municip municipality so I would like to have um Ben come up and we can discuss any questions or changes you might have I know we have some great questions from uh Barbara Ben Como that that emailed out to all of us so we're going to address some of those and answer also any questions that you may have thank you Clint before we move on I think c um board member Corin has um a question and counc plotus I guess I have a question and I just really this is really just me throwing up several Red Flags uh I know that Frank Bryce has dementia so I I want to be transparent and I know that he had dementia when he signed this paperwork so I would beg a lot of questions that he's the person that we can count on to make those decisions I know that um the county has had a history with Kelly Barker that was included a lot of misinformation and ultimately ended very badly uh so I think that's also that also raises significant questions so and the it from what you said everyone on the board resigned so that's a third red flag for me in terms of where this money is coming from this is separate from the idea of a 501c3 friends of organization I have really deep-seated questions about how this money is would be coming to any organization um I would want Buy in from a board of a community organization that existed and if they resigned abruptly that's pretty red flag to me so so I I just think I regardless I understand the idea of a friends and I think we should consider it um as a possibility I don't think that this is these are the conditions that uh seem right to um take money from an a community organization via a person who I I don't think we should really have a lot of faith in in terms of their governmental relationships and history of um kind of questionable Behavior within within that space so um so that I guess I just really want to raise those red flags and I think they're separ frankly I think they're separate from the idea of having a 501c3 or a friend of organization um and I would really like us to consider I don't I'm not I don't want us to quash the idea of a friend of and all the things that go into that because of this um but I also would say that for me there are some ethical considerations that I think uh are deeply troubling in this series of events you're stating that Mr Bryce had dementia that was never told to me I never that's brand new information I don't know how we can confirm that with HIPPA laws and things like that I know that he moved into he sold his home and moved into their own or uh living facility so I I personally know the folks in the animal community and have heard this from many of them so so I mean sure there are HIPPA laws and then there's also um a person a different person who I think is not a reliable act actor working on behalf of someone it's very very suspicious to me sorry yes and to address that as well she contacted me and I can show you the conversations we had and it was because it's all via messenger and uh she said she did not want to be involved with the with this organization at all U she said she was as a friend helping connect the dots with Mr Bryce but she didn't want not want to be involved in this organization she didn't want to be on the board she doesn't want any of that coner just a moment concer lus um well I think that um I have the same thoughts and sentiments as um counselor Coran so I need not repeat it all but um but I do have to emphasize that uh the woman in question is um someone that we should not be associated with at all so thank you um thank you for being eloquent about it um board member SEL Hernandez is um is there money tied to this or is it just the nonprofit status that we'd be taking over so they do have an account and it had $511 in it okay and that money was sent to us already oh it's already there yeah we did not ask for it Granite Mountain I believe it is is they sent it to us and that just was received on Monday or Tuesday there you go all [Music] right and went to the center yeah well it was given to us in it's given as a gift what it's given to to the city I don't know no so there was there was no communication on what one moment please one moment do would you like to have the floor um board member Flores or if you have some questions I'm happy to give you the floor no I uh please accept my apology for interrupting uh board member s Hernandez thank you board member SEL Hernandez um no no problems uh I think the question now just is is since the money is already not in the account now in the hands of animal services that does pose a different question as I did not know who this person was until I talked to Google about it um so my question would be is we do have a presentation correct there's a PowerPoint for this uh that was the PowerPoint that was it that was everything that was everything just giving you the information of how this came to be and now we're open for questions to so it sounds like there's two issues that we have is one with the person of how this came to be and second of what this organization is going to be okay and that was the purpose of this discussion was to to let you know this is what we're thinking we have our attorney here that can talk more in the legality of best methods for this organization of is it going to the method the words of financial arm was used and just clear up that confusion of of how I see it happening okay Madam chair what I would recommend is there definitely needs to be a discussion on what this mechanis or what mechanism this is and how it's being used and utilized and so on and so forth I think that's a great idea I think it's probably a better idea to start an our own nonprofit 501c3 status for Animal Services Center and not take over someone else's I think might be a better idea right now especially with individuals tied to it um so I would love to entertain the conversation of having a friends of I am strongly opposed to taking over the um previous nonprofit 501c3 personally ditto councelor Flor thank you Madame chair ditto um so I I agree 100% with uh board member um saljo Hernandez and uh but I do have a question about that check where is it uh we have it in our safe I think you should return it to it was that sent by the woman in question no it was sent by the the credit union sent it's a Credit Union check credit union what was the name of the credit who what is the I mean the can't the credit union may be the you know whatever the holder of the money but and there may have been some communication on that end between Mr Bryce and uh Barker and the credit union saying that's all closed send it to the ascmv we did not have any communication that a check was coming uh we just knew that there was money in the account I did not give a go for it to come neither did Bernice because we were like what's this check for when we got it to whom is the um check written out to the ascmv okay m M de do can you shed some light on some uh in that regard do you have any knowledge about how to handle a situation like that um board board chair um Madam Flores if this is a donation which Clint gets plenty of donations last year he received $47,000 in donations if this is what they want to do is they want to bring it in as a donation with I'm assuming no strings tied to it we can deposit that check in the in the bank um it would go into our bank and then it would be on the books for Animal Service Center thank you yeah and that that was the that was the idea of it but then it clicked the name of the credit union so I can reach out to the credit union and find out what their what they want us to do with this check that did they mean it for money to go into the new 501c3 that could possibly be done and that's their starting money for it that that was our worry of why we didn't just go ahead and deposit the money and cash the check but um Mr ther the credit union is just the uh vessel of the transferring of the money it's not the the owner of the money so um who it was the Humane Society the one that uh disintegrated is that the one the it was Society of Southern New Mexico's account it was okay somehow um I feel really squeamish about that and um I would U again um concur with uh the comments by uh board member sjo Hernandez and board member Kuran um and I would like to emphasize that we should not have any connection whatsoever um with Miss Barker and uh and agree totally with uh with uh the uh capacity of agree with counselor excuse me board member Karan as to um Mr Bryce's mental capacity I think if there's any doubt and um I mean I'm I'm not I'm not privy to his his uh mental status but if there's any doubt we should uh definitely be careful about that and I don't know how to go about that at this point um I'm I'm relieved to learn that the check is sitting there in your safe um but somehow I I the whole thing is just uh it's problematic for me and I I have no recommendation or solution uh just a request that uh I I think maybe run it through your attorney um maybe we have to run it through Finance um but yeah it it just doesn't um yeah thank you board memberes board member de Madam chair thank you if I could ask Clint if you is the check made out to Animal Service Center in msia Valley yes ma'am and there's nothing else on there I would have I would assume and I know you have your attorney here but I would also assume that if they were wanting to use it for the 501c3 they probably just would have left that bank account open and it sounds as if and I don't know and we can we Finance can help Animal Service Center we can work with Bernice and look at this uh because it sounds to me that probably what they did somebody went to that credit union closed that account maybe and said can you please send the you know send a money order or check to Animal Service Center and that's because you're saying that it's not from their bank account but actually from a bank you well Credit Union thank you yeah it doesn't say if I remember correctly the check does not say Humane Society southern New Mexico on the upper left it's the actual Credit Union yeah and um Madam chair it sounds to me that what they probably did was close out their bank account so even if you tried to send it back there probably is nowhere to send it back to so we would need to NE you know talk to the bank as well to see what their recommendation is because they would need to reopen that or they would probably put it in unclaimed property and then it would sit there in that unclaimed property so thank and I like I mentioned before I'm sorry thank you board member um de Clint I'm sorry I was goingon to say that like I said before I don't have any problems of making contact with the bank they have to keep some type of record of why this money was sent was it requested to be closed and we can we can find that information out that would be my recommendation is to um direct you recommend that you communicate with the credit union um and and just understand if this was a donation a contribution to the Animal Services Center um because if there it's money but it doesn't have any attachment to doesn't say the Humane Society so I would recommend that you do your due diligence and figure that piece out um I'm sure Ben can help it's been a long time Ben good morning um and I would that's what I would do okay it will be done okay um Ben's here please come to the podium and speak on behalf of what you have found out um related to the 501c3 I think did you get a copy of board member beno's um concerns and I think it behooves us to have you go over those and see if because it sounds like and and it's been the will of this board for many um years um this has been a goal of Clint and I think it it it's it feels like it's more um visible and attainable and it may not necessarily be with this but I'd like to hear from you Ben thank you thank you very much Madam chair I appreciate that um good morning uh members of the board for those of you I have not met before my name is Ben young I'm an attorney with Minette Springer here in town we've been representing the Animal Services Center for many many years um and uh so it's a pleasure to assist in matters like this I come up and relatively uh new type of issue and I think that the spring board for this conversation again is um what Miss Barker bro to back in May and that was what was able to assist with reinitiating this conversation a lot of the things that were just commented on earlier we can address I I believe the hsmm financial accounts were all being handled by their accountant which is who I had been in contact with over the summer um so it would be a relatively simple thing of contacting the the accountants office to find out exactly what transpired with the exchange of funds it is at the stage we're at in the in the communications with the on the 501c3 transfer or change of designation issue all that we had received up to this point was that resolution which authorized the Animal Services Center to work with the accountant on determining whether or not this was a feasible thing for the asnb to do or not so it's we're very early on in the in the process with them um I I don't think and correct me if I'm wrong on this Clint I don't think the the shift for hnm to be associated with the ascmv was ever about the money in the accounts but more about the connections and the historical work that hsmm had done whether or not they had contacts with other Grant entities and those types of things if they did have historical um accounts with different entities that that would be something of value it wouldn't be a brand new 501c3 starting from scratch developing these new relationships but it would be something that would already give us boots on the ground moving forward I had no indication when this stuff started that how the nature of Mr Bryce's illness um but that may if if it is what if he didn't have capacity to sign this at the time in September we may have to revisit that issue so that's something we can treat differently um as far so so now transitioning into the friends of organizations the over the course of the last couple months I think there had been some confusion as to what exactly the board wanted um with respect to this organization did we desire it to be a subcommittee of the ascmv that was tasked with going out and Gathering um funds whether from Grants or different entities and then bringing that to the board for the board to decide how to use it or were we looking at establishing or use whether using the existing 501c3 that tweaked its Mission or establishing a new 501c3 who is tasked with obtaining grants funds connections with different people to benefit the ascmv independently and so those are that that was an area of direction that we needed from the board there are pros and cons to both uh to both structures the the pros of of having an independent 501c3 as a friend of or a foundation type relationship kind of what the university has um is that they can operate and get connections with entities that have no strings attached can give money to a 501c3 get all the charitable deductions that they need which are not always available for government entities the issue that government enti or that individuals run into who want to give money to a government entity is there are some types of Grant that don't qualify for the charitable deduction and so they would rather give to a 501c3 than to a government entity um and that's where the benefit and so if we go that route it's a much larger broader world of Financial Resources the difficulty with that though is you do have a SE completely separate independent board um that has to have its own structure that has I would recommend strongly have its own attorney have its own CPA all of those things so they would need to be organized separately but they do exist only for the purpose of benefiting the ascmv I know historically there's been some difficulties with those types of relationships that have turned sour and that's where a lot of the questions in the email from uh from board member Beno were were were addressed to the benefits of having the uh The Entity serve more as just a subcommittee that you form it's easy to set up and you have complete control over what they do and how they gather resources and where they go about um asking for for donations but the world of of resources that they have available to them is limited um they don't they wouldn't be able to do what Clinton did this morning and just plug in a Google Search and apply for every one of those uh items and or apply to every one of those entities and receive the the donations or the grants um a lot of them would be exclusive of a subcommittee of a government entity so that's where we stand I'm happy to we don't want to go we didn't want to go too far down either Rabbit Trail until we had clear direction from the board we want this and then we're able to assist with setting those things up if the board does want to go the 501c3 route there will be a lot of uh interconnected I think working there will be some legal aspect uh from the ascmv side but I think there will be a lot of community networking that will need to be done there will need to be board members recruited there will need to be um by those board members then an attorney potentially retained who's willing to do those to do that work for them I'm happy to answer questions now or thank you Ben yes Council um board member SEL now you're a council member sjel Hernandez board member um like I said I think that the 501c3 status would be great I think that's fine um um after hearing two options thank you for those two options um option one sounds like the more beneficial way to go through this for funding but also after sitting on many boards that are nonprofit and seeing how many nonprofit boards there are in Las crues that benefit Animal Service and Welfare here in in our beautiful city and town um It's A Hard One to kind of stomach I mean funding is limited everyone's going after the same dollar um I don't know if we want to also have a another board that's looking at other finances separate from the finances that we're looking at on a daily basis but I would love to see like where the funding is going to be used how it's going to be used what they're going to go after are we going to give strict parameters of let's go after you know Education Services and this and that or is it going to be broad or the other option which you said was to bring it under us which limits their capacity but also and maybe um lean maybe that's something that you can help answer for us because if Animal Services is already getting donations from public from Estates whatever it is the money is going into the operating account and being dispersed I would guess so we're already not kind of designating where those donations are spent they just go into General operating then they go towards the $30,000 walls for the kitty cont or you know things like that so I I like the idea like I said but I want to see parameters of where where your vision is and where you want to see this go because like I said you're seeing you know they just closed Humane Society of Southern New Mexico they you know they're disbanding and they have $500 in their account that kind of speaks volumes to me of like what are we actually capable of doing in our community with limited resources um um so personally I just want to see kind of a layout of where you want to go with this how you want it to be set up do you want to see it as a board that someone's going to have to manage someone's going to have to run you know grant writers I don't know if we have a separate board is the city or the county going to come in and offer grant writing services probably not that's probably going to be something that's going to have to be funded by this board with no money in an account so I just don't want to see it being a huge burden one on you Clint because you do have a lot on you have two facilities that you're running um but also on this board that already is struggling to put forth finances every year and go through that I don't want to add another element of headache um but I would like to see where your vision is on this and direct parameters of where the money is going to go and how it's going to go but Lan if you have insight to this I would love to hear it because I think I'm kind of on the right direction here but please do chime in so um board chair the the friends as in so we have a couple of friends like the friends of the library and and that's a good one they provide they go out and they get um financial means to buy books for the library they help with publicity you know for educational programs and things like that um we do not monitor them in any way I don't think believe that staff is actually on the board or have any really direct connection with them other than probably attending and letting them know what their needs are things like this as um the counselors will know in the past we we have had issues you sort of alluded to it that we have had some issues with one friends group in particular and it caused quite a bit of uh controversy around and and we're still dealing with even things now trying to make sure that we abide by what um an big audit that we had done you know Council Flores um alludes to it multiple times at the finance select committee making sure that I'm on track and making sure that I dot my eyes and cross my tees and I thank her for that I think uh one of the items that um Miss benom had in her email was how do we keep this separated um if it's they're going after grants that affect our facility our operations that is really funding that should come into the Animal Service Center so that way the board has Direction on helping to spend those funds but with friends M and maybe Mr Young can help us it's a total separate entity there would not be brought to this board at all and hopefully I've answered your question I apologize and board member Madam chair I'd be happy to address that at least a little bit a lot depends on the structure of the bylaws um that is that are ultimately approved the the way that I understand the 501c3 regulations for this type of entity the friend of the foundation that exists for the benefit of some other entity um is that you can put particular parameters in there to ensure that the funds and from certain portions are used in a particular type of way another way to ensure at least some level of accountability it wouldn't be control or oversight because that's what we need to avoid but it would be something like having one of either one of the board members or staff or someone who we would the the the board would designate as an ex official member of that 501c3 so they wouldn't have voting responsibility but they would be able to participate in terms of presenting the needs of the shelter saying this is what these are the grant areas that we need that we need to prioritize right now whether it's we're talking facilities um we need we need a new veterinarian um let's focus on finding grants to fund that staff position uh whatever it may be that that can be stru you could have someone who's sitting in there in the regular board meetings whose task is to advise them that they would then have to take that into account in the structure of of how their bylaws are go ahead Madam chair um I think that's great in theory but if there's any kind of Staffing that's being funded usually those grants are accessible through local and County government and those are where those grants should be um acquired accessed and used it shouldn't be through a friends organization to pay for a staffing position that is funded by the city and the county um that's where we get into really Muddy Waters especially with a policy board so I'm going to have to say that's kind of not where the scope of a friends organization I want to see go um but like I said and you know if we can get Maybe a little consensus on this I would like to see a scope of Clint where you want to go with this you were given two options by our attorney where do we want to go how are these funds going to be used because I think we should be going after every non or um every gr dollar possible but we also are you know we're jpa with the county and the city and we do a lot of these things already so I just want to make sure that we're not stepping on toes and not making it hard for both entities to do the work that they need to do to help Animal Services if if I may thank you um board member Shel Hernandez I have you um board member Corin um we have a grant team here with the city that doesn't focus on animals that's why we created the grant writer position which has been vacant for some time and work in and and we started to look at the number of areas um that we could spend our time on um more specifically to help supplant or leverage the money that the city and county give and and we had been with the grants she had written pretty successful um and so I don't agree that our grant teams here at least in the city um specifically address animal animal issues it our sites are in other other bigger um bigger things not that Animal Welfare isn't important to me it is um but it's it's second or third fourth it's way down in the priority and we don't look for those kinds of things if there is an opportunity um to work together what I see is we have a lot of animal um Advocates that are working in a lot of different areas is to receive grants and some of the reasons why we had worked hard to agree that this overarching group that has all the advocates in one space was to work on minimizing the work the silos and to work towards some of the more priority areas but I don't know that that has evolved over time and since then we've had two or three different coun um boards um changes so I know this has been something as a longest standing board member that Clint has wanted to do this sort of fell in his lap and it was something that I thought could work um and and so I think I I don't disagree that Clint should you know this is what I'd like to see happen and what the areas are priority Spa areas that we could work with in tandem with a 501c3 um but I I don't believe that at least through and I'm looking at Leanne because she has more of the our our grant team does not specifically address these sorts of things and and she can say more about it but um I know that one of the bigger issues was focusing and leveraging the funding that we do have um currently and that's why we have a grant writer to work on that um Clint thank you well you're going to talk about this issue here yes you alluded to one question that I wanted to ask and and Ben you're probably the best to answer this is what's the difference between option number two which was to have a subcommittee and that's going to be pursuing grants and us having already a grant writer that writes grants on our behalf well at the Clint uh and Madam chair at the I guess there wouldn't be too much difference in in except maybe what you would do is you would give the grant writer position the oversight of a subcommittee and they're they're M possibly tasked with doing the community networking that needs to be done to find access to things locally or or at least in a a local Geographic scale that she might not be able he or she might not be able to um address indiv individually so you have a committee of volunteers potentially of people designated by the board to help with in that capacity and then her his or her position would um would allow the application for various different grants primarily so it sounds like there there would be a lot of duplication in in having a grant writer on staff and also having this option two of having them pursue it it just it seems like option one is the way that we would like to be make like um commissioner said be the most beneficial to the the center as far as what what they would be doing you know grants in the animal industry are an interesting thing there's some that are very specific um like the list that I pulled up senior animals very specific but it's just to benefit senior animals it's not so then we have to come up with a program to that's going to benefit and then we apply for that Grant uh sometimes it's just for General support and we apply for it and we get selected and we can do whatever we want with the money so uh as far as saying what we would do or what the friends of would be is yeah they would get direction from from us hey do you will you please pursue a grant for Education we have an education program where people can go we have staff that can go into a school will teach the kids about being safe around animals and wide licensed Etc the grant will pay for Education material it will pay for for this and this and this and then they would pursue that Grant they'd go after it so that is my thinking you know of um of what this friends of would be doing but if if we get more specifics from the board of whether to pursue this specific 501c3 then I can get you more specifics of you know possible board members or possible um direction to go how many we can get bylaws all that but if the board does not want me to pursue it U because of the history that it has that's perfectly okay we and we'll continue to look for other options um my problem for the last six years I've been here we I have had I've asked would you be interested in starting a 513 would you be that and I've asked several people and the answer is no they're just too busy um and and and so that's why I felt this was attractive because like uh attorney said we already have a lot of things in in the books so to say as far as contacts and instructions things like that that we need to have thank you Clint um board member Corin so I'm just gonna say no I my my recommendation would be that we do not take up a 501c3 that already existed in the community I don't don't think that it's parallel enough to a friends of organization I think a friends of organization that establishes a governmental relationship takes a lot more um effort so I would just I I don't I I would say no Um this can if someone wants the hssm moniker or 501c3 I don't I'm not comfortable with us taking that over and I don't think that would be an appropriate start to our whatever if we wanted a nonprofit arm and I would also argue aside from the seeking grants this is also something to kind of I will be frank about it skirt the anti- donation Clause because friends of organizations don't have the same rules related to the anti-d donation clause and I think there's a lot of legal gray area in there that would have to be parsed out that's very different from a community- based 501c3 that I that's why I feel like this I don't think it's um advisable for us to take this up I think it It's too convenient frankly um and I have concerns about the origins of it so uh if and again I think establishing a friends of is not a not a bad idea potentially depending on all the things but it doesn't sound like anyone has the capacity to do that right now from what I can hear in terms of the amount of work that would be required to to go into establishing that so I would argue I would say that we um say no to this opportunity um just because I don't think it's quite so simplistic to just adopt a 501c3 that's in a governmental organization that's that's associated with something like the city and the county so I guess that would be my the short of my my thinking on this um but I defer to you all too Madam Vice chair thank you um board member Corin if I could I I want to say thank you for the bluntness and being straight up forward it it helps us a lot to be able to move forward so thank you thank you Clint board member flotes thank you Madame chair um my question is this um a and um count uh board member Coran touched on it um I don't think it's within our purview uh to uh be intertwined with the 501c3 at all uh I think we need legal advice from our City attorney and the other is um the other would be the financial aspect you get that 51 C3 money and does that go does that go into a line item with our budgeting and our financial uh you know our finances so um I'm very um and and and the issue that uh that councelor Coran raised raised is whether a governmental entity um has any um such as the because it's a governmental agency um whether it has um whether it has any autonomy uh to to go after a 501c3 because because the the uh Animal Service Center is a fun of our jpa between the city and and the county so the question is um how viable or how legal uh would it be I think that you have to look at the relationship that the center has with two governmental bodies not just one and um and whether a 501c3 can function uh with that governmental uh control and I'm just uh I think we need answers do you did you research that part or do you know well uh Madam uh counselor the the by virtue just by virtue of being a jpa the Animal Services Center is still an independent government agency that's how the statute sets yeah these up so it is an entity that can apply do everything that is the the statute reads that they can apply to do just about anything that they need to that's permissible for other government entities in the state of New Mexico financially employee wise and so this would be a permissible thing relationship to have as well if it's permissible for one type of government agency to have the 501c3 relationship again it's it's a 501c3 that's created that has its own bylaws that expressly State we exist for the purpose of assisting this entity and the resource sources and the information and the benefits That We Gather flow through us to that entity to assist in the mission of that entity so that's that's how that structure works now whether or not the the board thinks it's prudent or wise at this time to do that that's that's your your call um but it is something that that does exist it's I not familiar off the top of my head with other jpa entities that have this type of relationship but that's something that can be looked into further if we would like but by virtue of being an independent government quasi government entity that has independent structures and and exists to pursue different things that the city and the county are not doing because they've delegated that authority to the ascmv they're able to do that okay and that was one of the benefits of uh Miss Barker Frank Bryce so just just saying in terms of the the springboard conversation I know that there is um issues with with that relationship and that so I'm not commenting on that I'm just saying that in terms of an entity approaching the ascmv and saying hey we're interested in converting our broad mission statement for what we exist to do in this community and narrowing the focus of it to exist only for your benefit they can do that and that's what triggers this conversation and so then if it's advisable to pursue that relationship maybe maybe not or if the board wishes to go a different route and see if there is interest in the community of of people who would like to exist in that capacity to benefit the asmb that's these other entities that exist locally don't exist in that capacity they exist in their own personal mission based hey we want to do X Y and Z for animals in the community they don't exist for the purpose of benefiting the ascmv right but um that may be true but um there there is a difference in so far as whether that money was designated specifically for a certain purpose we don't know I don't know um the other is that um in in you know the the example that uh Miss Deo um our finance director Miss Deo brought up um about the um we have the friends of the library but the friends of the library um is functions so differently I mean it's they they meet upstairs and at the at the uh banigan Library um and and they do a lot of things for the community um and uh but the Animal Service Center and and they don't have the added um infrastructure that that forms the uh as uh CMV they don't have a joint Powers agreement with anybody in the world and and that is my concern my concern and I'm not I I would like to um I I think there's just so many ifs and so many unknowns um and uh and I'm not entirely sure that I understand it all I mean I understood what you said but um what I should say is that I'm not firsthand knowledgeable and I would so and councelor Flores that that is precisely why we're here today to have this conversation because we the Clint is asking for direction to learn more about these options to go down One path the other path or no paths um having the knowledge of the friends of the library organization however it may be that that could be helpful we can then sit down and talk with board member Deo and see if we can get connected with whoever is in charge with Friends of the library and see what their structure is and maybe if that is something that works well with the city and they do exist independently of the city as was described that might be the model that we follow and their their mission statement is just changed to reflect the asmb instead of the library correct and I it would we'd have to look at if we were to go down this road we'd really have to look at the um freestanding um like a sovereignty of theirs uh separate and apart from the city and that that would there therein lies the rub uh so um I think that there are more questions and answers at this point um and uh at this point I mean I I mean when I was at at the at the new center I this is so beautiful and and just on the way home I thought oh it'd be great if we had a 501c3 but when I say we I'm thinking more of our community and and I have to detach the city and my representation uh of and for the city so um so we still have a lot of questions to answer I think it's be wonderful to have that and what wait a minute what happened to our um grant writer and how long has she been been gone uh Elaine left us it's probably been about six months now at least but she's on contract and she does contract work with us oh so she's still available to do grant writing yes yeah she's written two grants for us since she's been on contract okay and the grant writing that she's done has it been fruitful have you got good Returns on it have not been or it hasn't been answered yet so it hasn't been processed and selected but if you remember she does it has been fruitful we've received numerous funding um when she was hired I remember that but it's been quite some time since there have been a report on that but anyway so anyway I think that there's just more questions and answers can you give some direction to Clint because I think that's what he's asking yes there's questions but how does the board want to direct him to move forward it sounds like very clearly and I'm going to S I'm going to put this is no to the Humane Society use of the 501c3 it looks like there's enough um concern about that but it it it begs the question do we move in this direction and if so what are we directing Clint to do at this point about a friends of the Animal Services Center I don't think we can really direct him because we don't know where to what we we we as a as um one of the parties to the jpa have to establish what our parameters may be or our limitations and uh whether it's possible to have um to have just a SE total separation you know the is it possible for the U for the center to have a um 501c3 that is totally separate and apart from the city and I don't know know if that was the case if someone could say oh yes it could be set up that way um that would be great but I don't think that the city uh really has um I I would need just a lot more clarification if the jpa status would allow us to even have uh you know be somehow involved with the jpa and um and what it would uh you know how it would impact the board we wouldn't be able to tell you what to do with that money um it's not our money and I don't know I don't know I it just and then would that money be comingled with the money that that the city yeah so we wouldn't that would be a totally different bag thank you Flores um for me I think and maybe you can answer this Ben um because you are the attorney um for asmv um I'd like for us to explore it I think there needs to be a considerable amount of u more research done about these kind of JP pasas that exist and is there some out in the nation that utilize a friends group um would be my direction to Ben and Clint um I think um councel flid does you make some great points about our attorney having the city's attorney look at whether this is something that can exist um um from the city's perspective I think you make a great Point um but and how would the duties be distributed would it be a board you know that's separate and apart like other friends um boards are specific to this to this particular area that would be my my recommendation to Ben and Clint and to board member dush because you're here from the city anybody else any um feedback from the um public please make your way down Jerry and States your name for the record thank you madam chair and members of the board hi Jerry Wheelis um would there be any problem with just community members getting together and establishing a 5013c for the benefit of the shelter has nothing to do with the city that's I mean that's on the table right yes ma'am I know my leg too uh Clint ther executive director I there still the issues that were coming up was if the you have no control over the money that's coming in the money comes in what do you do with it I mean if if it's a group of citizens that come in and give us money that's great it's a donation um currently right now what we we do with donations if it's a specific donation for a specific reason we come to the board and we say this to accept this donation for this specific reason and then the board accepts it or denies it and then it's used for that specific reason or we get just a general donation say we like to give you $50 and it goes in our donation line item so that's currently how we do it but I don't see a difference between a 501c3 giving us money and a group of citizens giving us money for a specific reason reason and then how it's handled but that's just me do you you have any difference it would eliminate a lot of the strings if a communitybased 5013c gave you donations and board um board chair we would I would probably need to get with our City attorney um we also have a I also have a tax attorney that works with us as well and so we probably would need to seek out advice and I maybe even and the County Attorney as well so seek out advice I I don't think that we're saying that for for financial purposes okay we're not saying that the 501c3 wouldn't work I think um establishing the board and having those bylaws as long as they're very clear and precise of how you know the funding will be and what it's going to be used for and the grants that they're going after so that way there's no co-mingling and and just you know for events and things like that that we just make sure that um you know that we don't um the past doesn't happen again um I'll just say it that way so I know that um Clint as you know Kathy and I have talked about um we've kicked around the idea of a 5013c um for the benefit of the shelter so if you need assistance with that thank thank you thank you jar thank you thank you thank you okay next up are the dates oh go ahead and make your way down please hello please state your name for the record hi I'm Tina dor actually that's my business name and I'm planning to dissolve it and I was going to do the nonprofit rather than doing a profit because my zen pet cemetery hasn't made any money but I'm getting a sizable offer which I want to go somewhere and that's why I came to this meeting because it was thrilling to hear that I could put that money toward and it's $44,000 so it's way more than the 500 but I haven't accepted her offer yet because I didn't want the money and if I give it to Clint to answer your question I don't get a tax deduction they don't give tax deductions or do you you do okay but when you're making a sizable one because I do it every month because I find people in the community that want their cats space I pick females and if they can't pay for it I put it in their donation box instead of well no for the ones that do pay I put another $40 In Their donation box so then they get actually $80 for every female cat they spay thank you so I really would like to see it go forward whether it goes under the old one or I will convert my business to profit them because I don't want the 4,000 I could use it in my life just like everybody else but I want it to go to them because $40 a spay that means a hundred cats can get spayed with my 4,000 and that would be my purpose is to give it to them for the 4,000 or the 100 cats thank you my mission is getting those female cats and dogs I haven't started the dog part yet yeah but I'm determined to get as many Spade as possible for the oppr population thank you so much foring in your comments forgot how much did you get as donations do you know the remember I'll P the number 45,000 it seems like if some of the community members in the community I'm sure will be putting in way more than 47,000 if they got that ta tax write off and got recognized for making that donation I appreciate that thank you so much please consider something for it thank you okay now Clint you're up with the dates for November and December thank you madam chair I uh did not do a presentation for this because it's just Cal calendaring what we have is our fourth Thursday coming up in Thanksgiving one two3 is the 23rd of November and that is on Thanksgiving so we need to discuss a new day for the board meetings so either the 16th or the 30th uh if you want to keep it on a third Thursday but we do need to decide on a date is the city um Chambers available for those dates that I do not know right off the top of my head I would say you need to know that first before we agree right we can agree to look into it maybe the 30th would be better I don't know but and then or leave 1630 and then 16 16th and 30th can we get um Leanne someone to look at that as we're M moving through um the the rest of the agenda so we can confirm it's really hard to get all of us together and agreeing on a date and so we've agreed 16th and 30th but it depends on the chamber availability yeah board chair let me look into it real quick if I need to run down the hall I will thank you thank you thank you and the next date's the same or the next thing's the same for December uh we just need to know know if you still want to move forward on the 28th of December for a board meeting no no you do not oh I don't any other feedback please no I I don't okay 21st would be better choose another day 21st if you want to keep it on a Thursday sounds good sounds good that would actually work fabulous for me because I was going to be out of town on the 28th so I'm going to be out of on the 21st on the 28th okay okay so we check going out you're having surgery okay you got some dates uh in case I this building is or meeting this room sorry this room is not available can we look at the 14th as well as option b because if we do November 16th that's still almost a month in between the two it works for me okay that would just be an option b in case the 21st isn't avail ailable okay so you should probably let Leanne know yeah I will all right thank you because she's looking at it right now okay that's all that's all that discussion was thank you thank you Clint okay any public comment as our next item okay um board member comments seeing none okay can I get a motion to adjourn so movees shelder Hernandez second Corin motion made by um board member CIO Hernandez second by Council cor Becky please take the role board member Ward yes board member Flores yes board member Kuran yes board member shayo Hernandez yes chair Gand yes motion passes thank you thank you all for bearing with us